Never, never ask why

I was preparing for my nursing boards the other day by doing practice questions. I don’t remember what the question asked, but the rationale indicated that asking “why” was nontherapeutic because it could come across to the patient as accusatory. More on that later. However, there is a lot to be learned about therapeutic communication for life in general. With the social landscape so polarized, here are a few things that might help you connect with those around you better.

Pause & Retreat

Peter McFadden describes how to effectively use this concept in his article “Time-Outs Taught Me How to Handle Conflict” for Verily Magazine. However, this is something I have had first had experience with. I had just met a guy I really liked. I definitely wanted to get to know him better and maybe even something more. Then, another young man came in like the great American Eclipse. I was alarmed and confused.

Mr. Eclipse had tried to initiate things with me previously, but I wasn’t interested. I was turned off by the way he jealously intercepted conversations with my male friend. Now, Mr. Eclipse was suddenly best friends with Mr. Interesting. To add insult to injury, he became increasingly friendly with me again. Mr. Interesting was becoming increasingly distant.

I tried to push Antagonist away while getting a little more aggressive about pursuing Mr. Interesting. To make a long story short, Mr. Interesting was not interested and got very uncomfortable.  That lead to a couple uncomfortable verbal exchanges then some written exchanges.

Finally, I called a time-out “to process.” After that, Mr. Intresting and I had one of the most productive conversations. I felt much better and he verbalized that I had showed by my words that I understood [him]. Sometimes, you have to take a moment to like raging emotions calm down and then talk.



I pulled my dearest friend out of his introverted shell by arguing with him because I couldn’t figure out any other way of getting to him. Yet, arguing was marvelously effective! He had a particular attraction to these heated conversations.

Now, we were sitting in his car driving over miles of California desert to visit my relatives and another argument was about to start. I had just told him that I didn’t see things from his perspective and his face was twisting up. I didn’t argue this time. I told him a story. I was able to see things from my perspective. It turned out that he didn’t see things that differently from me. I was effective and it strengthened our friendship. Storytelling is important.

Picture: Pexels


When I heard that protesters were vandalizing Confederate statues all over the country, I thought it was a piece of nonsense. To me it was an unnecessary destruction of history. To me Robert E. Lee wasn’t a bad man. He was only a man that caught on the wrong side of the war for personal and perhaps political reasons. My cousin gently liken the confederate statues to Nazi swastikas posted in a Jewish neighborhood. Even though swastikas are symbol of the cross. I stopped a moment to step in to the shoes of the wounded children of slaves and feel their feelings. I agree that those Confederate statues could be very hurtful. That being said, let’s find a productive and professional way to deal with them.

Picture credit: J. M. Wilson


So back to the concept of never asking why. Although I couldn’t find any more information about why it was untherapeutic to ask “why,” they did suggest asked the client more about how he felt about the situation. That seemed like a sneaky way to ask why. So, never ask why, but always be questioning? That’s how I saw it. Choosing the right words to reach a person is also a key to great communication.


What are your keys to developing great communication with the people around you?

Featured photo by Asa Rodger on Unsplash

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.